Compare and contrast sun tzu and clausewitz

Among many such theorists, the works of Sun Tzu and Carl von Clausewitz are widely referred to.

Compare and contrast sun tzu and clausewitz

Army Radio Program

Sun Tzu was a prominent military advisor to Chinese nobility around B. Two basic tenets of his writing were to prepare adequate defences to repel any attack and to seek ways to defeat the enemy.

Carl Von Clausewitz is a Prussian soldier and German military theorist who stressed the moral and political aspects of war. He lived in the late 18th and early 19 th century. He was directly influenced reforms within the Prussian army that led to defeat Napoleon.

In his writing he advocated viewing war and politics as one. The warfare must be remaining under the direction of the political leaders to achieve its aims. Clausewitz SunTzu Thepoliticalobjectiveisanoriginalm otiveforthewar.

Itwillbedeterm ineboththem ilitaryobjectivetobereachedandtheam ountofeffortitrequires. Thevalueoftheobjectm ustdeterm inethescarifiedtobem adeforitm agnitudeandalsoinduration.

Ashem ention m aneuverforleverage M ilitaryisthelastresort 'W henthearm yisengagedinprotactedcampaigns,theresourcesofthestatewillnotsuffi ce attackenem ystrategy Net 'Thoseskilledinw arsubduetheenem y'sarm ywithoutbattle.

Sun Tzu never defines what war is but he only said that war is a matter of vital importance to the state. His primary goal is to find a way to defeat the enemy without actually fighting him.

According to Sun Tzu, this should be the first goal of any commander. In war, if a commander can force his enemy to capitulate without either side paying a high price in blood, the resulting peace is likely to be arrived at more quickly, and be easier to manage.

Bitterness and animosity built up over long periods of fighting leave deep scars and foster grudges between enemies. According to Sun Tzu, this is less of a problem by a quicker and less costly war. Sun Tzu promotes fluidity, flexibility, surprise, deception and intelligence over sheer military might.

According to him, the proper application of these principles will allow the wise commander to win. Wise commanders who seek to keep their enemy guessing, off balance and reacting instead of acting is well on their way to victory.

Sun Tzu sees the use of force almost as a last resort in war. This approach preserves lives, property, and public support for the government or commanders who apply it wisely. Clausewitz was largely preoccupied with the massive application of force and attempts to mitigate friction in combat operations.

He defined friction as suffering, confusion, exhaustion, Comparison of Sun Tzu and Clausewitz: The problem with his line of thinking is that he became a slave to the concept of a single definable centre of gravity.

It is a combined effort of compare/contrast Sun Tzu and Carl von Clausewitz's philosophies and how they apply to America's current War on Terrorism stance. Essay by Axis_of_Evil, University, Master's, A+, February download word file, 27 pages, 2 reviews4/5(2). Sun Tzu emphasized that there is nothing comparable to a victorious army and on the other hand, Clausewitz believes that the best strategy is to get stronger and stronger (Ando). Choosing between these two is difficult because they both have strengths and weaknesses. Comparison of Sun Tzu and Clausewitz: strategic thinking on war Sun Tzu is an ancient Chinese military general, strategist and philosopher who is traditionally believed, and who is most likely, to have authored the Art of War, an influential ancient Chinese book on military strategy. Sun Tzu was a.

Clausewitz stressed the importance of finding the centre of gravity or the critical point at the critical time which is the outcome of the conflict depended. These multiple smaller centres of gravity can be individually exploited and isolated in the pursuit of overall advantage. By exploiting several centres of gravity simultaneously, the enemy can be quickly thrown off balance.

Clausewitz did not see the importance of unconventional operations and how they could decrease the effectiveness of large opposing forces without the need for a decisive clash of massed strength. He also did not pay attention to how friction could be used against the enemy.

A general strategy should focus on this destruction of the enemy forces. Repeated human wave assaults focused on the strongest points of enemy defences, while attempting to smash the enemy into defeat.

This mentality served only to bleed both sides at similar and alarming rates. The new automatic weapons of the day made human wave assaults little more than mass suicide. The tanks and aircraft of that era were not fast or powerful enough to play a decisive role in gaining advantage through manoeuvrability.

Comparison of Sun Tzu and Clausewitz: Sun Tzu tends to lean more toward a goal of victory regardless of method.Sep 15,  · In terms of military strategy; how will you compare Chanakya, Sun Tzu, Machiavelli and Clausewitz?

How influential is Clausewitz in modern military theory?

Save Time and Improve Your Marks with Cite This For Me

Sun Tzu vs Napoleon vs Clausewitz vs Chanakya: Who is the best strategist? The Battle of the Military Theorists: Clausewitz vs. Sun Tzu It is in these views that Clausewitz and Sun Tzu differ greatly and based on my study of military strategy in history, I adhere.

This paper compares the two philosophies provided by ancient Chinese Sun Tzu and Clausewitz to understand which philosophy is complete and effective. After discussing both the philosophies I argue that in fact, Sun Tzu is much more Superior then Carl von Clausewitz’s philosophy.

Sun-Tzu & Clausewitz: A Comparison.

Compare and contrast sun tzu and clausewitz

August 5, August 4, by Patrick Shrier. Both Sun-Tzu and Clausewitz have something to offer for the serious student of warfare. The biggest distinction between the two seems to be their different approaches to the art of war. Sun-Tzu is a Go player while Clausewitz is the chess master.

There is. It is in these views that Clausewitz and Sun Tzu differ greatly and based on my study of military strategy in history, I adhere much more to Sun Tzu’s views in this area.

Comparison of Sun Tzu and Clausewitz: strategic thinking on war Sun Tzu is an ancient Chinese military general, strategist and philosopher who is traditionally believed, and who is most likely, to have authored the Art of War, an influential ancient Chinese book on military strategy. Sun Tzu was a.

Compare and contrast sun tzu and clausewitz
Sun-Tzu & Clausewitz: A Comparison – Battles and Book Reviews